Earlier this month I attended the NACFB Expo talk called ‘The Funding Trap’ and a discussion about businesses turning to fast, short-term funding to manage their cashflow and talked about high-cost lending, loan-stacking and repeat refinancing, and the roles that brokers, lenders and policy makers play.
The alternative finance market has been hugely positive for SMEs. It has increased choice, improved speed and allowed many businesses to access funding when traditional banks have been unable or unwilling to help. There will always be a place for fast, flexible finance, particularly where a business has a short-term cashflow gap, a clear repayment route, or a specific opportunity that needs to be acted on quickly.
However, speed and access should not come at any cost.
A growing concern is the rise of high-cost short-term business loans and the practice often referred to as ‘loan stacking’ where a business takes on multiple short-term facilities, sometimes at the same time and sometimes one after another, until the combined repayment burden becomes unmanageable.
The problem is rarely one loan in isolation. The problem is the cumulative impact. A facility that looks affordable on day one can become very expensive when layered with other borrowing, daily or weekly repayments, renewal fees, personal guarantees and broker commission.
In the worst cases, and we are seeing more and more of these, businesses are not funding growth at all. They are borrowing to service borrowing.
This is where the role of the advisor is critical. A good advisor should be advising and not just distributing. Their job should be to understand the business, its cashflow, its existing commitments, its repayment capacity and the purpose of the funding.
When we as Snowball are raising debt finance in the market, technically that work means we could be classed as a credit broker, and indeed we have direct FCA authorisation to undertake credit broking. However, anyone that knows us, will have heard me say that I hate the word ‘broking’ being used for elements of what we do because it lumps us together with a large number of ‘brokers’ in the finance market who in my view do a very poor job for the customer, but a good job for themselves. We ‘advise’ the best option and alternatives for the client.
This is a problem equally with both brokers and lenders because the lenders enable this bad behaviour and poor advice. The first thing many lenders say to us when they come in to see us is ‘this is how much commission we will pay you’ and often followed by’ the more deals you give us, the higher the levels of commission’ – this is wrong!
And many of the online portals used by brokers to lenders even allow the broker to set the level of the commission they can charge the client. This topic was raised in the discussion at the Expo and became a little tetchy as the lender was accused of enabling the situation to get worse by saying their brokers set their own levels of commission. To be fair the lender in question is not the worst one out there by a long way!
Unless something changes soon, there is no doubt in my mind that regulation will be coming and maybe even a redress scheme somewhere down the line.
Whilst I can’t say the FCA, the industry regulator, does a great job in the wider sector at the best of times, if the industry can’t regulate itself properly, which at the moment I don’t think it can, then regulation will come.
At Snowball we don’t have any issues with this as we have a business model different to virtually the whole market. We do not take commissions from the lenders. We work for the client and are paid direct by the client. That way the client knows we are working for them and we can access independently the whole market and the issue of commission and fees is irrelevant. This also enables us to access more than 600 funders across the UK.
High-cost credit and consolidation of that debt isn’t really an area we get too involved in as much more of our deals are for funding for growth, but I am seeing more and more of these deals and they have all been badly advised.
Some examples include a deal where our advice was actually to tell the client not to take out any more lending because that was the wrong thing to do, but it is the right advise to give to the client, and another where a client had 6 different short term loans with 4 different lenders, all short in duration and all paying in excess of 40% interest and the broker who I won’t name earning 12.5% commission on each deal. After the loan period expires, no doubt they will be ‘advised’ by the same broker to move somewhere else for another set of fees for some further short-term funding.
At Snowball, our view is simple. Funding should start with the business need, not the product. Advice should be independent. Costs should be transparent and in our view commission should not be taken as they distort the recommendation. Fast money can be useful, but badly structured debt can quickly become a trap.



