This book is written by Andrew Ross Sorkin who is one of America’s best known financial journalists. He is a long-time writer for The New York Times, author of ‘Too Big to Fail’ about the 2008 financial crisis, and co-creator of one of my favourite TV series, Billions.
In the book Sorkin turns his attention to probably the most famous financial collapse of them all. It was based on eight years of research and tells the story principally through the people involved, the bankers, businessmen, politicians, investors and speculators, who all thought the boom could last indefinitely.
The Boom Before the Bust
America during the 1920s was experiencing enormous change. New technologies were transforming everyday life, consumer credit was expanding, businesses were growing rapidly and ordinary Americans were increasingly being encouraged to participate in the stock market. Shares ceased to be something owned purely by the wealthy. Investing became aspirational!
The difficulty was that investment increasingly became speculation. People borrowed money to buy shares. Investment trusts multiplied. Insider dealing and practices that would now be regarded as market manipulation were commonplace and often perfectly legal. Groups of wealthy investors created stock pools that could accumulate shares, push prices upwards and encourage the wider public to buy into the excitement.
The problem was everyone started to believe it would just go on and no. Rising markets justified greater borrowing, greater borrowing created more buying, more buying pushed prices higher.
The Characters
The book is split across the different key characters of the time.
One of the central figures is Charles Mitchell, chairman of National City Bank, the predecessor of today’s Citigroup. Mitchell was one of the most powerful bankers in America and an evangelist for expanding access to investment. As markets began collapsing, Mitchell remained determined to project confidence. National City was itself pursuing an enormous acquisition of Corn Exchange Bank which relied heavily on the value of its own shares remaining high.
Another interesting character is John J. Raskob, a senior figure at DuPont and General Motors who subsequently helped finance the Empire State Building.
Only months before the crash, Raskob became associated with an article entitled Everybody Ought to Be Rich, advocating regular investment in the stock market as a route to wealth for ordinary Americans. The timing looks extraordinary with hindsight. Raskob genuinely believed that wider participation in capitalism could increase prosperity.
Then there is Jesse Livermore, perhaps the most colourful character in the book.
Livermore was a legendary speculator who repeatedly made and lost fortunes. While almost everyone else was betting that markets would continue upwards, he eventually took a huge position betting on them falling. His reward from the crash was reportedly around $100 million. Yet even that did not secure his future. Livermore subsequently lost most of his wealth and finally committed suicide.
There are plenty of other recognisable names including Winston Churchill, Groucho Marx and William Durant, the founder of General Motors, who continued pouring money into shares in an attempt to support the market as it collapsed.
The Crash
The crash itself did not happen in a single moment. During October 1929, confidence began to disappear. On Black Thursday, the 24th October, some of America’s most powerful bankers gathered at JP Morgan and organised a buying operation reportedly worth around $100 million in an effort to restore stability. It didn’t work!
Selling returned with enormous force, culminating in Black Monday and Black Tuesday on the 28th and 29th October. The market was overwhelmed by the volume of transactions, where ticker-tape prices could not keep pace with what was actually happening on the trading floor. Investors did not always know what their holdings were worth.
The crash was the first domino to fall but what followed over the next several years was bank failures, collapsing confidence, tightening credit and a series of policy mistakes and this turned a financial crisis into something vastly more destructive and turned into a depression. Sorkin argues that whilst 1929 was a key moment, the mistakes then made in the following years actually caused the depression more than the events of 1929.
The Backlash
Public attitudes towards America’s bankers then changed dramatically. The Pecora investigations exposed conflicts of interest and practices that had previously remained largely hidden from the public. The balance of power shifted rapidly from Wall Street towards Washington.
The response eventually included the Glass-Steagall reforms separating commercial and investment banking, deposit insurance and securities regulation through the newly created Securities and Exchange Commission. In only a few years, America’s financial system moved from one with extraordinarily limited regulation to one with considerably greater government oversight.
Some of the lessons from the book are:
Good Times Disguise Risk
When revenues, asset prices and confidence are rising, weaknesses can remain hidden. Businesses should probably think hardest about the downside when everything appears to be going well. This is not in the book, but it reminds me of the quote from Warren Buffett who said ‘Only when the tide goes out do you discover who’s been swimming naked!’
Debt Changes the Consequences
Borrowing was fundamental to the 1920s boom. Leverage did not necessarily create every problem, but it magnified what happened when asset values fell. The same applies to businesses today: debt can accelerate growth, but the structure, level and ability to service it under different scenarios are critical.
New Technology Does Not Justify Every Valuation
Radio was one of the transformational technologies of the period and companies such as RCA captured investors’ imaginations. The technology was real; that didn’t mean every valuation attached to it was sensible.
It is difficult to read that without thinking about the dotcom era or today’s enthusiasm for AI.
Beware of ‘This Time is Different’
Almost every financial bubble develops reasons why traditional measures no longer apply. Usually, the arguments contain some truth. The economy really may have changed. Technology really may create enormous opportunities.
The mistake is turning those truths into a belief that risk has disappeared.
Liquidity and Resilience Matter
A business can be profitable and still fail if it cannot meet its obligations when confidence and liquidity disappear. Having sufficient headroom, funding and contingency plans rarely looks exciting during the good times, but can become invaluable when markets turn. Definitely a lesson for today as well!
It is a decent book. Whilst it is a history book it doesn’t read like a text book and I liked the story developing around the main characters and these characters were followed right through the rest of their lives.



